Goldman Sachs36 min
How Small Business Owners Are Dealing With Worker Shortages, Inflation and Supply Chain Delays
Joe Wall, Allison Nathan, Ruby Bugarin, Kari Parker, Rosemary Swirk
Interview, Webinar
Survey Context and Sentiment Shift
- Goldman Sachs launched the "10,000 Small Businesses Voices" initiative in April 2020 to amplify small business input in federal, state, and local policymaking.
- Prior data indicated a systemic lack of representation: only 9% of owners felt they had a strong voice in policy, and just 7% believed federal officials prioritized small business issues over large corporations.
- Small businesses were virtually absent from political discourse, appearing in only 2 out of 14 presidential and vice-presidential debates during the 2020 election cycle.
- A recent September survey reveals a 29-point drop in optimism compared to June: sentiment that the U.S. is moving in the right direction fell from 67% to 38%.
- This decline is attributed to three primary drivers: the Delta variant's impact on consumer-facing sectors, accelerating inflation, and persistent workforce shortages.
Inflation and Supply Chain Disruptions
- 81% of small businesses report increased inflationary pressures since June, with 84% experiencing rising operating costs.
- 74% of respondents state that inflation has negatively impacted their financial health.
- Specific price volatility was cited by restaurant owners: avocado costs surged from $40 to $85 per case within weeks before stabilizing at $60, still significantly higher than pre-pandemic levels.
- Supply chain delays are doubling project timelines for construction firms, with pre-engineered metal building delivery times extending from 12–15 weeks to 25–52 weeks.
- Manufacturers are increasingly refusing to guarantee prices or delivery dates due to the unpredictability of the supply chain.
- Port congestion involves tens of thousands of containers stuck in the distribution cycle due to labor shortages, lack of containers, and trucking deficits.
- Business owners note that shortages span diverse categories, including to-go containers, plastic cups, crab meat, and steel, preventing operations from running at full capacity.
Workforce Challenges and Wage Inflation
- While 73% of businesses are hiring, 87% report difficulty recruiting qualified candidates.
- 80% of owners indicate that hiring difficulties are directly impacting their bottom lines.
- 64% of businesses report that workforce challenges have worsened compared to pre-pandemic levels.
- Staffing shortages are driving substantial wage inflation; one contractor reported losing an employee to a competitor offering a 40% higher wage.
- Restaurant owners have increased hourly rates by $2 to $3 per hour, yet still face high turnover and difficulty retaining experienced cooks and dishwashers.
- Connie's Chicken and Waffles spends 2.5 to 3 hours daily on staffing, a significant increase from the 30–40 minutes required pre-pandemic, resulting in a workforce reduced to roughly 75–80% of pre-COVID levels.
- Mental health issues are affecting 49% of small business owners and employees, rising to 70% for female owners under age 45 due to childcare and pandemic-related stress.
Disparities Facing Black-Owned Businesses
- Black-owned businesses are experiencing a lagging recovery in staffing: median employees dropped from 9 pre-COVID to 6, whereas the overall sample recovered to near pre-pandemic levels.
- Only 20% of Black business owners are very confident in their ability to access capital, compared to 31% of the overall sample.
- 51% of Black business owners hold less than three months of cash reserves, surpassing the 44% figure for the general small business population.
- 54% of Black business owners anticipate needing to take out a loan or line of credit in the coming months, nearly double the 29% rate of the overall population.
Forward-Looking Statements and Policy Recommendations
- Construction executives warn that supply chain constraints are projected to persist for another 12 months, necessitating major detrimental adjustments to business planning.
- Restaurant owners express concern regarding winter spikes in infection rates, which historically reduce sales during the November–February period.
- Goldman Sachs advocates for a durable, long-term, low-interest fixed loan program to replace the expiring COVID EIDL initiative.
- The 10,000 Small Businesses Voices initiative is pushing for federal procurement reforms to reverse a 38% decade-long decline in small businesses contracting with the federal government.
- New data from the EIDL program now utilizes 2019 financials for qualification rather than 2020 data, which reflects pandemic-era losses.
- The EIDL program has recently been modified to raise the loan cap from $500,000 to $2 million with added flexibility for capital usage.
- Approximately half of the relief funds appropriated by Congress remain on the sidelines at state and local levels, prompting calls for faster dispersion.