Luisa

Highlights: Edge cases of sentience & acting ethically despite massive uncertainty | Jonathan Birch

Jonathan Birch, Luisa

Philosophy professor Dr. Jonathan Birch presents *The Edge of Sentience*, a work analyzing how "inductive risk" has historically led medical and scientific experts to undervalue potential suffering in neonates, vegetative patients, and animals due to overconfidence in current consciousness models. Drawing on cases like Jill Lawson's advocacy and Adrian Owen's fMRI research, Birch highlights the dangers of relying solely on expert consensus by proposing that citizens' assemblies should complement scientific input when setting bioethics policies for emerging technologies like neural organoids and artificial general intelligence. The book further argues for separating the legal right to abortion from debates on fetal sentience to prevent future scientific advancements from eroding bodily autonomy protections.